Roofing crew lead in a plaid work jacket and hard hat holding a nail gun on a shingled roof at sunset, another roofer working behind him

Comp Time Instead of Overtime in the US? Why You Can’t Bank Fall Hours for a Slow Winter

Your crew lead logged 35 overtime hours in October, and you've offered him a paid January week off to square it. That's comp time, and a private business can't use it: the $1,470 he earned is still owed in cash.

Your crew lead logged 35 overtime hours in October, and you’ve offered him a paid January week off to square it. That’s comp time, and a private business can’t use it: the $1,470 he earned is still owed in cash.

He’s happy with that, and on paper it looks generous. He’s paid $28 an hour. His three October weeks on the roof ran 52, 48 and 55 hours, and payroll paid him for 40 each week. The trouble is that comp time trades overtime pay for time off later, and US federal overtime law runs week by week. Each week’s overtime is due in cash on that week’s payday, and the January week counts toward none of it.

Why comp time can’t pay for October

The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) is the federal minimum wage and overtime law, and the Department of Labor’s Wage and Hour Division enforces it. Section 7(a) requires pay at one and a half times the regular rate for every hour over 40 in a workweek. That is a legal requirement, not a guideline.

Each workweek stands alone. A workweek is a fixed, repeating block of seven days, and the Department’s regulation at 29 CFR 778.104 says hours can’t be averaged over two or more weeks. A 55-hour week owes 15 hours of overtime, whatever happens the week after.

The money is due on time. Under 29 CFR 778.106, overtime earned in a workweek is due on the regular payday for the period in which that week ends. October’s overtime belongs on October’s paychecks.

Paid time off can’t stand in for it. Pay for a vacation, a holiday or a slow day with no work is not pay for hours worked. The regulation at 29 CFR 778.218 says “no part of such payments may be credited toward overtime compensation due.”

Comp time does exist in the FLSA, which is where the idea comes from. But section 7(o) gives it only to employees of a “public agency,” such as a state, county or city. A contractor isn’t one.

What the three weeks cost

The table assumes payroll paid him straight time for 40 hours each week and nothing for the rest.

Week Hours worked Overtime hours Overtime pay owed at $42
Week 1 52 12 $504
Week 2 48 8 $336
Week 3 55 15 $630
Total 155 35 $1,470
Illustrative figures: $28 regular rate, so $42 an hour for overtime. Rule: 29 U.S.C. 207(a)(1).

The January week would cost you $1,120, which is 40 hours at $28. It looks like most of the debt, but under section 778.218 it covers none of it. The full $1,470 is still owed.

If payroll did pay the extra hours at straight time, the gap is smaller. You’d owe only the missing half-time premium: 35 hours at $14, or $490. Watch bonuses too. A bonus you promised for hitting a target counts in the regular rate, so it raises the overtime figure. The overtime figures on your W-2s come from the same numbers, so it pays to get them right now.

Woman in a fleece vest at an office desk checking a spreadsheet of weekly hours, hard hats on a shelf and snow outside the window
Overtime is counted week by week, so the weekly hours record is what matters.

Moving hours inside the week or the pay period

You still have room to manage hours. It just has to happen inside the week, or at most inside the pay period, not across seasons.

Overtime is owed only on hours over 40 in the workweek. So a 10-hour Monday balanced by a 6-hour Friday in the same week owes no federal overtime. That’s the simplest lawful version of “taking it back in time off,” and it only works before the week closes.

The Department’s Field Operations Handbook describes one narrower arrangement its investigators accept. It is guidance to them, not a regulation. If you pay every two weeks, you can cut hours in the second week to offset overtime in the first. Each overtime hour needs one and a half hours off, so the paycheck stays level.

As an illustration, say the crew lead works 44 hours in week one and 34 in week two. The pay stub still shows four overtime hours at $42, and the two weeks together pay $2,240, the same as 80 straight hours. The handbook says this is “not payment for overtime in time off,” and that such plans are “rarely used.” It can’t work with weekly pay, and it can’t carry hours into another pay period, let alone move October into January.

Salaried exempt staff

An office manager or a genuine supervisor on salary, exempt from overtime, is under a different rule. The regulation at 29 CFR 541.602 requires the full salary for any week they do any work, however many hours that is. Giving them a quiet week in January is your call. But a crew lead who works on the tools and is paid by the hour isn’t exempt because of the title. Our article on reporting time pay covers the salary rules for a foreman in more detail.

California adds a daily rule

California’s Labor Code section 510 adds overtime after 8 hours in a day, and double time after 12. So even the 10-hour Monday creates two hours of overtime there. Section 513 allows “make-up time” in the same workweek, but only when the employee asks in writing for personal reasons, and you can’t suggest it. An old state provision, section 204.3, does mention compensating time off. The state Labor Commissioner warns that using it “may result in violation of the federal law.”

Who’s covered, and the comp time bill in Congress

The FLSA covers businesses with $500,000 or more in annual sales, and it can also cover individual workers at smaller ones. State overtime law can apply where it doesn’t.

You may have heard that Congress is considering comp time for private employers. The Working Families Flexibility Act, H.R. 2870, would allow it. It has passed a House committee but is not law.

If you’ve already promised comp time

Tell the crew lead plainly that the deal has to change, and pay the overtime on the next payroll. The January week can still happen as ordinary paid leave if you want to offer it. It just doesn’t count against October.

Leaving it costs more. Under 29 U.S.C. 216(b), an employee can recover unpaid overtime “and in an additional equal amount as liquidated damages.” In this example, $1,470 could become $2,940. Claims normally reach back two years, or three for a willful violation, under section 255(a).

Keep the hours record honest while you fix it. The Department’s recordkeeping rule requires hours worked each workday and each workweek, and a timesheet that shows 40 when the crew worked 55 makes things much worse.

BEFORE THE WEEK CLOSES

See the long week coming while you can still move a job.

Overtime is settled week by week, so the only time to rebalance it is before Friday. SendWork shows each person’s jobs for the week in one schedule, so you can shift a job to someone with hours left before anyone passes 40.

See how crew scheduling works for US contractors →