HVAC technician in a grey uniform kneeling beside an outdoor condenser unit on a leaf-covered lawn, talking to a homeowner holding a mug, a white van parked behind

Service Contract or Maintenance Plan? When Free Repairs Bring In US State Law

Your $25-a-month plan promises free parts and labor on covered breakdowns. That line can make it a service contract, registered with the state and backed by insurance or a reserve. Here’s the wording that keeps a plan a maintenance agreement.

Your $25-a-month plan promises free parts and labor on covered breakdowns. That line can make it a service contract, registered with the state and backed by insurance or a reserve. Here’s the wording that keeps a plan a maintenance agreement.

Tune-ups, inspections, priority booking and a discount on repairs you still bill for are maintenance. “Free parts and labor on covered breakdowns” is not, and neither is “we’ll replace the unit if it can’t be fixed.” Those lines promise, for a separate fee, to repair or replace equipment that fails, and that is what makes a plan a service contract under US state law. Texas, Illinois and New York write maintenance-only plans out of their service contract laws in so many words. Florida and California draw the line in different places.

Three promises on one plan sheet

Say your top tier, the Gold plan, costs $25 a month. This is an illustration, not any real company’s plan. Its sheet makes three promises:

  1. Two tune-ups a year, priority scheduling and 15% off any repair.
  2. Free parts and labor on covered breakdowns.
  3. If the system can’t be repaired, we replace it.

On the wording of the Texas, Illinois and New York laws, the first promise is a maintenance agreement. You still bill for every repair. The customer just pays 85% of it. Those three laws turn on a promise to repair or replace after a failure, and none of them mentions discounts. Florida’s does.

The second promise changes the plan’s legal character. You are now taking the cost of a future breakdown in exchange for a monthly fee. That is the core of a service contract in every state law covered here. Pricing the visits themselves is a separate job, covered in our guide to building HVAC maintenance plans.

The third promise, replacement, is the clearest case of all. A plan that buys a new condenser or water heater when the old one dies is carrying a risk much like an insurer’s. Florida, Illinois, New York and California all regulate this kind of cover through insurance regulators.

Technician in a grey work shirt pointing at a blank sheet of paper on a wooden table while talking with a homeowner, a pen beside the page
A few words on the plan sheet decide whether it is a maintenance agreement or a service contract.

What makes a plan a service contract

Texas spells out the test as plainly as any state. Its Service Contract Regulatory Act, chapter 1304 of the Texas Occupations Code, is a mandatory registration law run by the Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation (TDLR). It defines a service contract as an agreement “entered into for a separately stated consideration and for a specified term” under which a provider agrees to repair, replace or maintain a product “for operational or structural failure or damage caused by a defect in materials or workmanship or by normal wear.”

That makes three ingredients: a charge separate from the job price, a fixed term, and a promise to fix or pay when something fails. A tune-up plan has the first two. The third is what turns it into a service contract.

Maintenance-only plans in Texas, Illinois and New York

The same Act says it does not apply to a “maintenance agreement,” which it defines as one that “provides only for scheduled maintenance for a limited period.” Illinois and New York use the same idea:

  • The Illinois Service Contract Act (215 ILCS 152) is a mandatory registration law enforced by the Illinois Department of Insurance. Its definition covers heating, cooling, plumbing and electrical systems of a home. It excludes “contracts of limited duration that provide for scheduled maintenance only.”
  • New York requires service contract providers to register under Article 79 of its Insurance Law, run by the Department of Financial Services. Section 7902 defines a maintenance agreement as scheduled maintenance “other than contracts providing for the repair or replacement of such property due to a defect in materials or workmanship or wear and tear.” Section 7901 takes maintenance agreements outside the Article.

Free warranties and business customers

Your own workmanship warranty sits outside these laws too, as long as it comes free with the job. Texas excludes a warranty “made without payment of additional consideration” that is incidental to the sale. Illinois and New York only reach contracts sold for separate consideration. Federal warranty rules still apply, and our guide to writing a workmanship warranty that holds up covers them.

Four of the five laws covered here are written around household products and homes. Texas, for example, says its Act does not apply to a service contract sold to someone who is not a consumer. New York’s Article 79 refers simply to “property,” so don’t assume a plan for a restaurant or property manager there is outside it.

What a service contract brings with it

Once a plan counts as a service contract, someone has to register, prove the promises can be paid for, and write the contract a set way:

State and law Who you deal with Backing the promises Cancellation and refunds
Texas, Occupations Code ch. 1304 Registration with TDLR Reimbursement insurance, or a funded reserve plus a security deposit of at least $250,000, or a $100 million net worth Cancel any time; full refund in the first 30 days, prorated after, fee up to $50
Illinois, 215 ILCS 152 Filing with the Department of Insurance; $1,000 fee, then $150 a year Reimbursement insurance, or a 40% reserve plus a deposit of at least $25,000, or a $100 million net worth Full refund within 30 days if no service given; pro rata after; fee up to the lesser of 10% or $50
New York, Insurance Law Art. 79 Registration with the Department of Financial Services; $250 a year Reimbursement insurance, or a 40% reserve plus a deposit of at least $50,000, or a $100 million net worth Full refund if returned within 20 days of mailing (10 if handed over at sale) with no claim
Florida, ch. 634 Part III License from the Office of Insurance Regulation; $200 a year A deposit of at least $50,000 for a new warrantor, plus a 25% reserve or contractual liability insurance At least 90% of the unearned pro rata premium back on cancellation
California, Bus. & Prof. Code 9855 Registration with the Bureau of Household Goods and Services Reimbursement insurance, or an escrow of 25% of deferred revenue, or a large-company net worth test Refund rules in the Civil Code; late refunds earn 10% a year interest

What changes in the contract and the cash

In Texas the contract must name the provider and state the price, the cancellation terms and what is excluded. Unless it is insured, it must say the provider’s obligations “are backed by the full faith and credit of the provider.” A Texas residential service contract must also promise that work normally starts within 48 hours of the customer’s request. Get it wrong and TDLR can sue for a civil penalty of up to $2,500 per violation.

For a two-truck shop, the deposit or insurance policy has to be in place before the first Gold plan sells, and the plan sheet becomes a contract in the state’s format. The other route is to sell a contract issued by a provider that is already registered, which then carries the obligation.

Florida: why the annual plan itself needs a second look

Florida licenses what it calls service warranties under Part III of chapter 634, Florida Statutes. It is a mandatory licensing regime run by the Office of Insurance Regulation. Selling a service warranty to Florida residents without a license is a first-degree misdemeanor under section 634.403.

Section 634.401 lists a “maintenance service contract equal to or greater than 1 year in length” inside the definition. Its exclusion is narrow. It covers maintenance contracts “written for less than 1 year” that contain no indemnification and give no discount on parts and labor “in excess of 20 percent.”

So a 12-month plan sits outside that exclusion on its length alone, and a 25% repair discount would take even a shorter plan out of it. Whether the plan is then a service warranty turns on the rest of the definition. The state’s own service warranty overview from the Department of Financial Services describes a service warranty as including a maintenance service contract of a year or more. If you sell annual plans in Florida, put the question to the Office of Insurance Regulation before the next renewal season.

Plumbers and electricians have one more Florida law to read. Part II, on home warranties, covers contracts to repair or replace a home’s “structural components” after wear and tear or an inherent defect. That term includes the plumbing and electrical systems. It needs its own license, backed by a $100,000 deposit or a smaller deposit plus a bond. Usual performance guarantees given with no identifiable charge are left out.

A service contract on equipment you sold or installed

Some states treat the company that sold the equipment differently, which matters if most of your plans sit on systems you installed.

Texas lists exemptions in section 1304.0041. Its Act does not apply to a service or maintenance agreement sold by a merchant who sells the product, including a heating, cooling, plumbing or electrical system, covering that product. It also leaves out your guarantee on repair or service work you have done. A Texas plan on a system you sold therefore stands in a different place from a plan on a neighbor’s unit someone else installed. If most of your plan customers bought their equipment elsewhere, ask TDLR before relying on the exemption.

Illinois goes halfway. A provider who is the builder or seller of the product only has to follow the disclosure, cancellation, record-keeping and enforcement sections. Registration and the financial backing do not apply to them.

California’s two laws

California runs two laws side by side. Its Insurance Code regulates “home protection contracts,” meaning repair or replacement coverage for a home’s systems and appliances, through the California Department of Insurance. That law excludes a contract issued by someone who sold, serviced or repaired that system before issuing it, as long as they are not in the home protection business.

The second law is the service contract article of the Business and Professions Code, sections 9855 to 9855.9. The Bureau of Household Goods and Services registers service contractors under it. Its definition covers services “relating to the maintenance, replacement, or repair of consumer goods,” with no maintenance-only carve-out. It counts the repairer of a product as a seller, and it leaves out electrical contractors. The article is currently set to repeal on January 1, 2028, unless lawmakers extend it. California plan sellers should check with the Bureau rather than assume either way.

The federal service contract rule when you supplied the equipment

The Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act is the federal warranty law the FTC enforces, and its definition is wider than the Texas, Illinois or New York ones. Under the FTC’s Magnuson-Moss interpretations at 16 CFR 700.11, even a cleaning-and-inspection agreement is a “service contract.” The Act mainly asks that its terms be disclosed fully and clearly in simple language. But under 15 U.S.C. 2308, if you supply the equipment and sell a service contract on it at the time of sale or within 90 days, you can’t disclaim implied warranties on it. That includes a plain tune-up plan signed on install day.

Wording a plan that stays a maintenance agreement

Rewritten, the Gold plan reads: two tune-ups a year, priority scheduling, 15% off any repair we quote, and our one-year labor warranty on every repair we make. Each visit is named with what happens on it: inspection, cleaning, adjustment, filter change. The labor warranty comes free inside each repair’s price, not the plan fee. Wording such as “covered repairs” or “no-cost replacement” is gone, because the plan no longer includes either.

None of those lines promises to repair or replace anything after a failure, which is what the Texas, Illinois and New York definitions turn on. In Florida, keep any discount at 20% or below, and put the annual term itself to the regulator. Do the same with the Bureau in California.

The breakdown promise isn’t banned anywhere covered here. It belongs in a registered, backed contract, yours or a provider’s, priced to carry the reserve it needs. A plan that renews on its own also falls under the automatic renewal laws for maintenance plans. Any service contract registration sits apart from your state contractor license.

WHEN THE UNIT DIES ON A TUNE-UP

The tech at the door should quote the 15%, not promise a free fix.

A tech who tells a plan customer “that one’s covered” is making the promise you kept off the plan sheet. SendWork keeps each plan customer’s terms and history in their record, so whoever takes the call sees what the plan includes and quotes the repair at the plan price.

See how US contractors keep plan customers’ records →