General contractor in a canvas jacket holding a clipboard and talking with a roofing crew lead at the tailgate of a pickup on a residential roofing job in autumn

Uninsured Subcontractor? How a US Workers Comp Audit Bills You for Their Crew

Months after the job, your US workers comp audit can bill you for an uninsured subcontractor. The $18,500 you paid a painter with no certificate now counts as your payroll. A current certificate, checked against the days each sub worked, keeps it off.

Months after the job, your US workers comp audit can bill you for an uninsured subcontractor. The $18,500 you paid a painter with no certificate now counts as your payroll. A current certificate, checked against the days each sub worked, keeps it off.

That’s one way an uninsured subcontractor costs you under workers comp. In states such as Florida and Alaska, the law also makes you responsible for the sub’s injured workers if the sub had no policy. Both risks turn on that same certificate. Florida’s statute and rules spell the process out, so the example is set there. Your state’s rules may differ, so check them with your state agency and your agent.

What an uninsured subcontractor looks like on a workers comp audit

Say you run a remodeling company in Tampa. Your workers comp policy ran from January 1 to December 31, 2026. A few weeks after it ends, the carrier’s premium auditor asks for your payroll records, your 1099 list and a certificate for every sub you paid. The worksheet that comes back lists three subcontractors. This example is invented, and so are its numbers.

  • Drywall sub, an LLC. You have a certificate showing a policy in force all year. The auditor leaves its payments out.
  • Roofing sub. You have a certificate, but its policy expired on June 30. The sub did two jobs for you in September, and you paid $22,000 for them. The auditor adds those payments.
  • Painter, working as a sole proprietor. You have his W-9 and paid him $18,500. You never got a certificate. The auditor adds those payments too.

That puts $40,500 of subcontract payments into your payroll under the class codes for roofing and painting. Suppose the rates on your policy for that work averaged $9 per $100 of payroll. That rate is invented for the example; real rates vary by state, class code and carrier. The extra premium would be $40,500 ÷ 100 × $9 = $3,645, before any modifiers your policy carries. You can’t add that to a customer’s invoice now. The jobs closed months ago.

What decided each line wasn’t whether the sub was a real business, or whether you had a contract. It was whether you could show coverage for the dates the work happened.

Why the law makes the sub’s crew yours

Florida’s workers compensation law is Chapter 440 of the Florida Statutes. The Department of Financial Services runs it through its Division of Workers’ Compensation, and coverage is mandatory for the employers it covers. Section 440.10(1)(b) says that when you sublet part of a contract, your employees and the sub’s employees on that work count as “employed in one and the same business.” You must secure compensation for all of them, “except to employees of a subcontractor who has secured such payment.” Paragraph (1)(c) adds the duty: “A contractor shall require a subcontractor to provide evidence of workers’ compensation insurance.”

Florida’s construction definitions close the obvious gap. Under s. 440.02(18)(c), anyone you pay as a subcontractor in construction counts as an employee unless that sub has its own coverage or a valid exemption. Sole proprietors in construction count as employees too. That’s the painter.

Alaska’s Workers’ Compensation Act gets there in one sentence. Under AS 23.30.045(a), if a subcontractor “fails to secure the payment of compensation to its employees, the contractor is liable for and shall secure the payment.” Other states word this differently, and a few take a different approach altogether. Read your own state’s text rather than assuming.

How the audit turns an uninsured subcontractor into workers comp premium

If your policy may have to pay for a sub’s crew, your carrier wants premium for that crew. A 2022 Alaska Division of Insurance decision (Case H 22-01) shows the mechanics. A general contractor’s final audit found a sub with no workers comp, and the carrier charged more premium. As the decision explains, the standard policy form approved in Alaska sets premium by the rules of the National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI), a licensed rating organization. Those rules apply there once the Director of Insurance approves them.

One of them, Basic Manual Rule 2-H, lets a contractor avoid premium for a sub’s work by showing evidence of the sub’s insurance or a certificate of exemption. That contractor had neither, nor the sub’s payroll records. So the full subcontract price became the premium basis, and the Director upheld the audit.

Manual rules are not statutes, and not every state uses NCCI’s. Some states have their own rating bureaus or state funds. Still, the official sources point the same way. Pennsylvania’s State Workers’ Insurance Fund, the state-run insurer operated by the Department of Labor & Industry, tells applicants that “any subcontractors that do not carry workers’ compensation may be included.” California’s State Compensation Insurance Fund tells policyholders that 1099 payments to uninsured or unlicensed workers “may be included in the audit as payroll.” So any uninsured subcontractor on your 1099 list is one your workers comp auditor will ask about.

Reading a sub’s certificate of insurance, line by line

The paper to check is the one-page Certificate of Liability Insurance a sub’s agent issues. Florida’s Rule 69L-6.032, a Department of Financial Services rule, lists what it must show to count as evidence of workers comp:

  1. Producer. The agent’s name, address and phone number, which is who you call to confirm the policy.
  2. Insurers affording coverage. The carrier that writes the workers comp, not just the general liability.
  3. Insured. The sub’s own name, not another company’s.
  4. Policy number. A workers compensation and employers liability policy number, or a binder number if the policy isn’t issued yet.
  5. Limits. Dollar limits for that coverage, filled in.
  6. Signature. An authorized representative has signed it.
  7. Dates. The days the sub works for you fall between the policy’s effective and expiration dates.

The last line is where the roofer went wrong. A certificate describes the policy on the day it was printed, and it can’t show a later cancellation. Florida’s rule requires new evidence if the work runs past the expiration date.

A certificate on its own isn’t enough in Florida. The rule also wants written confirmation from the agent or carrier, and a printout from the Division’s Proof of Coverage search counts as that confirmation. That printout, or a copy of the policy’s Information Page, also works on its own. And s. 440.05(7) lets you register in writing with the sub’s carrier, which then owes you written notice of any cancellation or nonrenewal.

Check the state as well. Section 440.10(1)(g) requires employers with employees working in Florida to carry a Florida policy or endorsement, so a Georgia sub’s home-state policy may not cover your Tampa job. Pennsylvania’s state fund likewise wants proof of coverage “in Pennsylvania,” so ask the agent if the state is unclear.

When the sub sends an exemption instead of a policy

Some subs answer the request with an exemption. In Florida that’s a Certificate of Election to Be Exempt, issued by the Division of Workers’ Compensation under s. 440.05. It’s optional: an eligible officer chooses to give up coverage for themselves, and in construction the request costs $50.

Who can have one. In construction, only corporate officers can elect the exemption. For this purpose the law counts LLC members who own at least 10% as officers. No more than three officers of a corporation may be exempt, and each must own at least 10% of the stock. A sole proprietor in construction can’t hold one, which is why the painter needed a policy.

Whom it covers. Only the officer named on it. If the sub has a helper or a crew, Rule 69L-6.032 says you need evidence of a policy for those employees as well as the exemption.

Which company. The certificate names a corporation. If the officer is working for a different company than the one listed, it doesn’t apply. The officer must also do work in the industry the certificate lists.

Dates. A Florida exemption runs for two years from its effective date, and both dates appear on its face. You can confirm it’s still active on the Division’s Exemption search, and keep a screen print.

Don’t assume every state has an equivalent. The Alaska decision notes that Alaska has no procedure for a subcontractor to obtain a certificate of exemption, so a contractor there needs evidence of insurance. An exemption also doesn’t settle whether someone is really your employee. That’s a separate test, covered in our guide to 1099 versus W-2 workers.

Keeping an uninsured subcontractor off your workers comp bill

The certificate is easiest to get before the sub has your money. Make it a condition in the subcontract, ask for it before work starts and hold the first payment until it arrives. Verify it the way your state allows. Then note the sub’s policy expiration date and ask for the renewal certificate before it passes. If a final payment is about to go out and the certificate has lapsed, ask then.

Office manager checking a manila folder at a desk with a laptop, a blank printed form and a pen in a small contractor's office
A certificate only helps if it matches the dates the sub worked, so keep the two in the same folder.

Keep each sub’s papers in one vendor file an auditor can read in a few minutes:

  • the W-9 you already need for the 1099-NEC (our IRIS 1099 filing guide covers the November W-9 chase);
  • every certificate of insurance or exemption, with your verification printout;
  • the subcontract;
  • the dates the sub worked on each job, and what you paid for each.

That last item does the real work, because a certificate with mid-year dates means nothing until you know when the work happened. Keep the file for your general liability policy too, which your carrier may audit on its own terms. And if you’re still settling when your own business must carry coverage, start with our state-by-state workers comp overview.

Florida gives you one more lever, in s. 440.10(1)(d). If an uninsured subcontractor leaves you liable for its employees’ workers comp, you can recover the benefits paid, plus interest, from that sub. The exception is a written agreement that you would provide the coverage. Still, that’s a claim against a sub who may have little to collect. The certificate is the cheaper protection.

Back to the Tampa audit

The roofer line is worth a call. If the roofer actually renewed on July 1, get the new certificate or the policy’s Information Page from its agent and send it to the auditor, who is looking for evidence that the sub was covered. Should the line stay, ask the carrier how to dispute it. But if the painter really had no policy, he was an uninsured subcontractor, and that workers comp charge stands. The fix then belongs to 2027: a certificate from him before his first check, or a different painter.

WHEN THE AUDITOR ASKS FOR DATES

A sub’s certificate only covers the days inside its policy dates.

So the question at audit is when each sub was on your jobs, not just what you paid them. In SendWork every job carries its schedule and whoever you assigned to it. The dates you need to hold against a certificate are on the job, not in last spring’s text messages.

See how job scheduling works for US contractors →